Al-Idrisi
Alas, George passed into paradise two years before the king. Would that he had lived longer! A great evil, of which I must now tell, might then have been avoided.
When George died, he was succeeded by Philip of Mahdia. Philip was my friend. He had been born a Christian, but he had become a Believer. He practised our faith in quiet, for the king did not look favourably upon apostates, although he loved the Muslims, so much so that some men called him, secretly, ‘the baptised Sultan’.
In the summer of the year one thousand one hundred and fifty three in the Christian calendar, Philip led the king’s navy to Bône in Africa, to help that city’s ruler to defend the place against invaders from the west. He succeeded in this mission, and returned triumphantly to Palermo. Some say that Philip was too grand and boastful in his victory, and that this show of glory did not please the king. Be that as it may, there were powers at work in Palermo, amongst the bishops and the Christian barons, who hated Philip. By their trickery they turned the king’s mind against his emir.
The King’s Private Chambers, The Royal Palace. Autumn 1153
(Enter Roger, Archbishop of Palermo, The King’s Chamberlain. Roger sits.)
Archbishop
Your Majesty, the news I have to bring you grieves me to the heart. Philip, chief among your ministers, has betrayed you. You have seen the vainglorious manner of his return from Africa. But there is worse. I have informers close to him. I know he gives himself to practices abhorrent to our faith. He eats meat on Fridays and on Ember Days. He visits synagogues. He sends gifts to Mecca, to the tomb of the prophet, requesting that the imams who preside that execrated place offer prayers for him. There is no doubt, from all the information I have gathered, that he, a Greek, a Christian born and your first minister, is of the Muslim faith.
Roger
These are only rumours, lord archbishop, although it is not the first time I have heard them. (To the Chamberlain) Let Philip be imprisoned for a short time; let him be treated well. Arrange an open trial with all speed. (The Chamberlain and Archbishop bow and exeunt.)
Al-Idrisi
So it was done. As soon as I heard of the Archbishop’s testimony against Philip, I went to see His Majesty. It was the only time, in our long friendship, that I dared to challenge his authority. I was afraid…
(Al-Idrisi crosses the stage to where Roger is still sitting.)
Roger
Good day, Muhammad. How goes the work?
Al-Idrisi
Well, Your Majesty. But it is not for that reason that I have come to see you.
Roger
For what, then?
Al-Idrisi
I come to plead for Philip.
Roger
Indeed? I had not realised that your considerable powers extend to legal advocacy. But proceed.
Al-Idrisi
Your Majesty knows that our people love you. There are other Christian princes, living and dead, who have persecuted us without mercy. The slaughter in Jerusalem more than fifty years ago still rouses us to anger. You have despised such acts. Indeed, in your own army the followers of Muhammad (peace be upon Him) have followed you into battle and fought bravely, often against Christian enemies. Here in Sicily, Believers occupy many high places in the governance of the state.
Roger
I know all this. What has that to do with Philip?
Al-Idrisi
It is not for me to say which faith he espouses. But I will say this: Your Majesty never had a more loyal servant than he. Men are plotting, even now, to blacken his name before you and before the court. Pay no heed to their lies, I implore Your Majesty. Wicked tongues will wag because their owners think thereby to gain advantage. See through their plausible wiles to their unworthy hearts.
Roger
What do you say to the charge that Philip has been vainglorious?
Al-Idrisi
If it be so, he should be checked. But a chiding, Your Majesty, will correct his fault more fitly than a crueller punishment. And he has many years left, God willing, in which to serve you.
Roger
But I have not many years left in which to be served. I am tired, Muhammad. Death stalks me. I hear his footfall behind me, approaching. I feel his breath on my neck. Soon he will tap on my shoulder. He has injured me already. I have not known true happiness since Elvira was taken. She bore me six children; five are in their graves. Only William is left. He is not the man that Roger, Tancred or Alfonso would have been. I fear for the kingdom after I am gone.
Al-Idrisi
Your Majesty should not give way to mournful thoughts. Consider your achievements: the glory of the kingdom, the wealth in our treasury, the trade with every part of the world; most of all, the love your subjects bear towards you.
Roger
Some of them, perhaps. But ‘The heart of man is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it?’ One of our more pessimistic prophets.
Al-Idrisi
And of ours, Your Majesty. We also venerate Irmiya.
Roger
As for Philip: who can tell truth from lies? I have listened to you; I trust your sincerity. But I have called an open trial, and we must hear it out. Enough, Master Idrisi. I have said that I am tired. Come another day.
Al-Idrisi (hesitates, and decides only to say…)
Your Majesty.
(Lights down on Roger. Al-Idrisi moves back across the stage to his seat at the side.)
The trial was open, but it was not just. The bishops and the barons had suborned false witnesses, who testified that Philip had committed all manner of offences against the Christian faith, had taken powers to himself which were the king’s sole prerogative, and even that he planned to lead a rebellion of Believers to overthrow His Majesty. After hearing many hours of this shameful deceit, the credulous and venal judges retired to deliberate, and returned quickly to the court.
The Throne Room of the Royal Palace. Autumn 1153
(Roger, Three Judges including Chief Judge, Archbishop of Palermo, The King’s Chamberlain, Philip are discovered. Roger sits on the throne. The Chamberlain stands beside him. Below Roger, the Judges sit. Before them, Philip stands.)
Chief Judge
Philip of Mahdia, a stream of witnesses have spoken with one voice. You are accused of apostasy to the true faith, of lèse-majesté in regard to your sovereign lord King Roger, and of high treason in plotting the dreadful crime of regicide. Have you anything to say before sentence is passed?
Philip
I swear before God that I have truly served His Majesty King Roger, faithfully executing the king’s commands both in this kingdom and beyond the seas. I have never thought to overshadow nor to overthrow His Majesty, to whom I owe every preferment I have had at his bountiful hands.
Chief Judge
What say you to the charge that you have secretly embraced the faith of Islam?
Philip
There is but one God, and…
Chief Judge
‘…and Allah is his prophet?’ Your Majesty, my lords, the man condemns himself out of his own mouth.
Philip
That is not what I was about to say. I was about to say that His Majesty is known throughout the world for his loving kindness towards all faiths which, in sincerity, search out the will of God.
(Roger rises from his throne. His voice trembles.)
Roger
Philip, the tears I shed for you are unbecoming to a king. The drumbeat of your greatness has, these recent months, been heard within these walls; and it has not pleased me. In spite of this, I would have forgiven you any crime against my own person; for I have loved you. But I have heard too much today of your delinquencies to stand in the way of the judgement of the court. Let sentence be passed. The king retires.
(Exit Roger.)
Chief Judge
Philip of Mahdia, we find you guilty of high treason. Your crimes, so clearly proven, merit condign, public retribution. We sentence you to death by burning; and may Almighty God have mercy on your soul. These proceedings are at an end.
(Terrifying music. Lights down.)
Al-Idrisi
So it was done. Philip’s feet were bound to the hooves of an untamed horse and he was dragged to the palace square. Before the horrified populace, his broken but still conscious body was burned.
Chorus [this is a ghazal, and should be accompanied by Arab-influenced music]
See how these prelates, judges, by their savage law
Appear as valiant defenders of their creed.
Appearances are vain; the truth is otherwise.
Where murder is the fruit, ambition is the seed.
Now Philip’s bleeding body is consumed by fire.
When we cry out for justice, who will pay us heed?
We have but one resort, our only advocate.
Great Allah, hear your people’s voices as they plead:
Convey your servant quickly into paradise
And visit vengeance on the authors of this deed.
Al-Idrisi
This was a dreadful action, which the king could have prevented. As it seems to me, Roger was weakened in his mind in his last months. He was a lesser man than he had been before. Otherwise he would have not have countenanced such wicked cruelty and grave injustice.
I pray to Allah for the soul of Philip, that it may rest for ever in a state of bliss. And that those who brought about his death and agony by their jealousy and lies may be themselves condemned to everlasting torment in the world to come.